The effect of constraint on the mechanical behaviour of trabecular bone specimens

The effect of the boundary conditions between trabecular bone specimens and the test columns of the testing machine was studied together with the effect of side-constraint on the mechanical behaviour of trabecular bone during axial compression. Cylindrical specimens taken from the upper tibial epiphysis of autopsy knees were tested non-destructively by cyclic compression to 0.8% strain under different conditions. Fixation of the specimens to the test columns by a thin layer of bone cement increased the stiffness by 40% and reduced the energy dissipation to 67% of those measured under unconstrained conditions (p less than 0.001). The thin cement layer alone increased the stiffness 19% and reduced energy dissipation to 86% (n.s.). When the machine was equipped with polished steel columns coated by a film of low-viscous oil, both the stiffness and the energy dissipation were reduced to 93% of those measured under standard conditions (p less than 0.005). Trabecular bone specimens tested side-constrained by the surrounding trabecular bone (in situ) showed a 19% larger stiffness than that measured during later testing of the corresponding machined specimens (p less than 0.005) whereas the energy dissipation was not altered significantly. The same specimens showed a 22% increase of stiffness and a 68% increase of energy dissipation when they were side-constrained by a closely fitting steel cylinder (p less than 0.005).