Can measures of critical power precisely estimate the maximal metabolic steady-state?

Critical power (CP) conceptually represents the highest power output (PO) at physiological steady-state. In cycling exercise, CP is traditionally derived from the hyperbolic relationship of ∼5 time-to-exhaustion trials (TTE) (CP_HYP). Recently, a 3-min all-out test (CP_3MIN) has been proposed for estimation of CP as well the maximal lactate steady-state (MLSS). The aim of this study was to compare the POs derived from CP_HYP, CP_3MIN, and MLSS, and the oxygen uptake and blood lactate concentrations at MLSS. Thirteen healthy young subjects (age, 26 ± 3years; mass, 69.0 ± 9.2 kg; height, 174 ± 10 cm; maximal oxygen uptake, 60.4 ± 5.9 mL·kg^-1·min^-1) were tested. CP_HYP was estimated from 5 TTE. CP_3MIN was calculated as the mean PO during the last 30 s of a 3-min all-out test. MLSS was the highest PO during a 30-min ride where the variation in blood lactate concentration was ≤ 1.0 mmol·L^-1 during the last 20 min. PO at MLSS (233 ± 41 W; coefficient of variation (CoV), 18%) was lower than CP_HYP (253 ± 44 W; CoV, 17%) and CP_3MIN (250 ± 51 W; CoV, 20%) (p < 0.05). Limits of agreement (LOA) from Bland-Altman plots between CP_HYP and CP_3MIN (-39 to 31 W), and CP_3MIN and MLSS (-29 to 62 W) were wide, whereas CP_HYP and MLSS presented the narrowest LOA (-7 to 48 W). MLSS yielded not only the maximum PO of stable blood lactate concentration, but also stable oxygen uptake. In conclusion, POs associated to CP_HYP and CP_3MIN were larger than those observed during MLSS rides. Although CP_HYP and CP_3MIN were not different, the wide LOA between these 2 tests and the discrepancy with PO at MLSS questions the ability of CP measures to determine the maximal physiological steady-state.