Transmission and decorrelation methods for detecting rare variants using sequencing data from related individuals

Advances in whole genome sequencing have enabled the investigation of rare variants, which could explain some of the missing heritability that genome-wide association studies are unable to detect. Most methods to detect associations with rare variants are developed for unrelated individuals; however, several methods exist that utilize family studies and could have better power to detect such associations.

Using whole genome sequencing data and simulated phenotypes provided by the organizers of the Genetic Analysis Workshop 19 (GAW19), we compared family-based methods that test for associations between rare and common variants with a quantitative trait. This was done using 2 fairly novel methods: family-based association test for rare variants (FBAT-RV), which is a transmission-based method that utilizes the transmission of genetic information from parent to offspring; and Minimum p value Optimized Nuisance parameter Score Test Extended to Relatives (MONSTER), which is a decorrelation method that instead attempts to adjust for relatedness using a regression-based method. We also considered family-based association test linear combination (FBAT-LC) and FBAT-Min P, which are slightly older methods that do not allow for the weighting of rare or common variants, but contrast some of the limitations of FBAT-RV.

MONSTER had much higher overall power than FBAT-RV and FBAT-Min P. Interestingly, FBAT-LC had similar overall power as MONSTER. MONSTER had the highest power for a gene accounting for a larger percent of the phenotypic variance, whereas MONSTER and FBAT-LC both had the highest power for a gene accounting for moderate variance. FBAT-LC had the highest power for a gene accounting for the least variance.

Based on the simulated data from GAW19, MONSTER and FBAT-LC were the most powerful of the methods assessed. However, there are limitations to each of these methods that should be carefully considered when conducting an analysis of rare variants in related individuals. This emphasizes the need for methods that can incorporate the advantages of each of these methods into 1 family-based association test for rare variants.