Acute abdominal pain: the value of liver function tests in suspected cholelithiasis

Over a 4-year period, prospective data were collected on 311 patients with suspected acute cholecystitis. By identifying the diversity of conditions which can masquerade as acute cholecystitis, we have examined the role of biochemical liver function tests in the diagnosis and management of these patients. The initial clinical diagnosis of acute cholecystitis was confirmed in 229 patients (73.6%). Of those patients on whom liver function tests were performed, 76.3% (206/270) were confirmed to have cholecystitis and 69.9% (144/206) of these had some evidence of liver dysfunction. In the group of patients (64/270) with other diagnoses on whom liver function tests were performed, significantly fewer (57.8%, 37/64) had abnormal liver function tests (P less than 0.05). This is of little clinical value since normal liver function does not exclude cholecystitis (predictive value of negative test = 30.3%). In proven cases of cholecystitis, there was a significantly increased incidence of liver dysfunction when ductal calculi were present. Using the information obtained from this study, an investigative protocol is proposed which may substantially reduce the rate of misdiagnosis of patients with abdominal pain suggestive of cholelithiasis.