The effects of initial population density on the competition for limiting nutrients in two freshwater algae

Eighteen long-term competition experiments were performed on two freshwater algae, a blue-green alga, Anabaena flos-aquae, and a diatom, Cyclotella sp., under controlled light and temperature conditions and various nutrient limitations. As predicted, Anabaena displaced Cyclotella when nitrate was in short supply to both species, whereas Cyclotella became dominant when both species were phosphate-limited. The two species stably coexisted when phosphate and silicate were limited. Anabaena either displaced or coexisted with Cyclotella when nitrate and phosphate or nitrate, phosphate and silicate were limited, depending on their initial density ratios. This study revealed strong effects of initial population densities on the outcomes of algal competition for limiting nutrients.