Differentiation of Crataegus spp. guided by nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometry with chemometric analyses

For compliance with US Current Good Manufacturing Practice regulations for dietary supplements, manufacturers must provide identity of source plant material. Despite the popularity of hawthorn as a dietary supplement, relatively little is known about the comparative phytochemistry of different hawthorn species, and in particular North American hawthorns. The combination of NMR spectrometry with chemometric analyses offers an innovative approach to differentiating hawthorn species and exploring the phytochemistry. Two European and two North American species, harvested from a farm trial in late summer 2008, were analyzed by standard 1D ¹H and J-resolved (JRES) experiments. The data were preprocessed and modelled by principal component analysis (PCA). A supervised model was then generated by partial least squares-discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) for classification and evaluated by cross validation. Supervised random forests models were constructed from the dataset to explore the potential of machine learning for identification of unique patterns across species. 1D ¹H NMR data yielded increased differentiation over the JRES data. The random forests results correlated with PLS-DA results and outperformed PLS-DA in classification accuracy. In all of these analyses differentiation of the Crataegus spp. was best achieved by focusing on the NMR spectral region that contains signals unique to plant phenolic compounds. Identification of potentially significant metabolites for differentiation between species was approached using univariate techniques including significance analysis of microarrays and Kruskall-Wallis tests.