Pooled sample testing for Bonamia ostreae: A tale of two SYBR Green real-time PCR assays

Pooled testing of samples is a common laboratory practice to increase efficiency and reduce expenses. We investigated the efficacy of 2 published SYBR Green real-time PCR assays when used to detect the haplosporidian parasite Bonamia ostreae in pooled samples of infected oyster tissue. Each PCR targets a different gene within the B. ostreae genome: the actin 1 gene or the 18S rRNA gene. Tissue homogenates (150 mg) of the New Zealand flat oyster Ostrea chilensis were spiked with ~1.5 × 10³ purified B. ostreae cells to create experimental pools of 3, 5, and 10. Ten positive replicates of each pool size were assayed twice with each PCR and at 2 different amounts of DNA template. The PCR targeting the actin 1 gene was unable to reproducibly detect B. ostreae in any pool size. Conversely, the 18S rRNA gene PCR could reproducibly detect B. ostreae in pools of up to 5. Using a general linear model, there was a significant difference in the number of pools that correctly detected B. ostreae between each PCR ( p < 0.01) and each pool size ( p < 0.01). It is likely that the single copy actin 1 gene is more likely to be diluted and not detected by pooling than the multi-copy 18S rRNA gene. Our study highlights that validation data are necessary for pooled sample testing because detection efficacy may not be comparable to individual sample testing.