Comparison of enamel remineralization potential after application of titanium tetra fluoride and carbon dioxide laser

The aim was comparison of enamel remineralization after application of APF, TiF₄ and CO₂ laser alone or in combination.

Enamel blocks were prepared from human third molars. The initial surface hardness was determined by Vicker's hardness tester. The samples underwent a demineralization regimen for 7 days to produce artificial initial caries. The hardness of enamel blocks with white spot lesions was measured, and the samples which had the mean hardness change of 65-90%, were selected, and randomly divided into 5 groups (N=15): G1: control; G2: APF 1.23%; G3: TiF₄ 4%; G4: TiF₄ 4% followed by CO₂ laser (10.6 µm wavelength, 1 W peak power, 10 ms pulse duration, 500 ms repeat time, 0.2 mm beam spot size, 2 cm distance); G5: CO₂ laser (same parameters) followed by TiF₄ 4%. Surface hardness recovery was measured after the treatments. Three samples in each group were observed under scanning electron microscope at ×1,000 magnification. Data were analyzed by repeated measure ANOVA and Bonferrouni tests. Significance level was set at 0.05.

G2, G3, G4 indicated significant differences with control and G5 (p<0.05). Surface hardness in G5 was not significantly different from control (p=0.7) in enamel hardness test. There was not a significant difference between G2 & G3, G2 & G4, and G3 & G4 (p=1). The SEM results indicated globules of calcium fluoride on the surface in G2, and a smooth glaze-like surface layer in G3 and G4. In G5, some micro-cracks without any glaze-like layer were observed.

APF, TiF₄ and TiF₄ before CO₂ laser irradiation significantly increased the micro-hardness of initially demineralized enamel surfaces. CO₂ laser irradiation before TiF₄ application could not remineralize the white-spot lesions.