Factors Correlated with Unfavorable Outcome after Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery

Carpal tunnel release surgery has excellent results. The aim of this study was to identify which baseline clinical and demographic factors could predict a good outcome from surgery. Understanding the impact of prognostic factors will enable surgeons to indicate surgical intervention better, provide appropriate preoperative counseling, and manage expectations postoperatively.

A prospective, observational study included 620 carpal tunnel syndrome patients (age 42.38 ± 11.18 years; mean ± standard deviation). After the diagnosis had been confirmed by electrodiagnostic studies, patients underwent open carpal tunnel release surgery. Patients were evaluated initially after 2 weeks and eventually after 6 months. Surgical outcome was compared with presurgical findings.

Response to surgery was good in 89.4% and 94.2% after 2 weeks and 6 months, respectively. Factors correlated significantly with unfavorable outcome of surgery included old age, longer duration of symptoms, negative Phalen's test, abnormal two-point discrimination test, and weakness of abductor pollicis brevis muscle. Gender, retrograde radiation, and nocturnal symptoms did not correlate with surgical outcome.

Elderly patients with longstanding disease, neurological deficits, and negative Phalen's test may not respond to surgery as others. This should be kept in mind in preoperative counseling and postoperative expectations.