Diagnosis and management of McFarland fractures

McFarland fracture is the eponym for a rare Salter Harris III or IV fracture involving the medial distal tibia. These fractures can be difficult to diagnose without a high index suspicion and appropriate radiographic imaging. These fractures may result in significant growth disturbances to the pediatric patient. When diagnosed and treated acutely, these fractures can be managed with cast immobilization and close follow up. If diagnoses in a delayed fashion they can result in significant morbidity including prolonged casting and possible surgical treatment.

In this case report we discuss a pediatric patient with a delayed presentation McFarland fracture which was initially diagnosed and treated as an ankle sprain. He required a prolonged course of treatment and we describe his clinical progression. We review the literature regarding this fracture pattern including history, acute management and outcomes. WHY SHOULD AN EMERGENCY PHYSICIAN BE AWARE OF THIS?: McFarland fractures are rare Salter Harris III fractures of the medial malleolus. These ankle fractures affect patients nearing skeletal maturity and may be difficult to diagnose without the appropriate orthogonal X-ray imaging. Also, a missed diagnosis can lead to unnecessary morbidity to the patient. If diagnosed acutely, these fractures can be easily treated with immobilization but if allowed to become chronic they require prolonged periods of casting and possibly even surgical intervention. A patient with a specific constellation of symptoms and history should raise suspicion for these injuries and prompt a thorough workup.