Related Experiment Video
Updated: Feb 13, 2026
05:02
Comparing Bibliometric Analysis Using PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science Databases
Published on: October 24, 2019
33.9K
Prestigious Science Journals Struggle to Reach Even Average Reliability
1Institute of Zoology-Neurogenetics, Universität Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany.
Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
|March 9, 2018
Summary
Journal prestige does not correlate with scientific rigor. Evidence suggests that the methodological quality and reliability of published research may decrease in higher-ranked journals, challenging traditional academic hierarchies.
Area of Science:
- Bibliometrics
- Scientific Publishing
- Research Integrity
Background:
- Journal rank is a primary metric for scientific career advancement.
- Prestige is often equated with superior scientific quality and reliability.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the relationship between journal rank and the methodological quality of published scientific research.
- To challenge the assumption that high-impact journals publish inherently more reliable science.
Main Methods:
- Analysis of quantifiable indicators of methodological soundness across numerous publications.
- Utilizing semi-automated data extraction from large-scale datasets of scientific literature.
- Circumventing confounding factors like readership and editorial scrutiny.
Main Results:
- Methodological quality does not increase with journal rank.
- Evidence suggests a potential inverse relationship: quality may decrease as journal rank increases.
- Reliability of published research may be compromised in top-tier journals.
Conclusions:
- The hierarchical structure of scholarly journals poses a threat to publicly funded science.
- Promoting scientists based on journal prestige may lead to the dissemination of unreliable research.
- Erosion of public trust in science is a consequence of publishing unreliable findings.
Related Concept Videos
01:23Journal Bearings
1.2K
Journal bearings are mechanical components that support and provide lateral stability to rotating shafts and axles. They are crucial in reducing friction, wear, and vibration in machinery such as engines, turbines, and pumps. The principle behind journal bearings is forming a thin lubricant film between the bearing surface and the rotating shaft, which minimizes direct contact and reduces frictional forces.
To better understand the concept of journal bearings, consider a rope winch with dry or...
To better understand the concept of journal bearings, consider a rope winch with dry or...
1.2K
01:29Reliability and Validity
14.1K
Reliability and validity are two important considerations that must be made with any type of data collection. Reliability refers to the ability to consistently produce a given result. In the context of psychological research, this would mean that any instruments or tools used to collect data do so in consistent, reproducible ways.
14.1K
01:30Average Acceleration
14.5K
The importance of understanding acceleration spans our day-to-day experiences, as well as the vast reaches of outer space and the tiny world of subatomic physics. In everyday conversation, to accelerate means to speed up. For instance, we are familiar with the acceleration of our car; the harder we apply our foot to the gas pedal, the faster we accelerate. The greater the acceleration, the greater the change in velocity over a given time. Acceleration is widely seen in experimental physics. In...
14.5K
01:13Psychology as a Science
4.0K
Psychology, as a scientific discipline, aims to understand the mind and behavior through rigorous and systematic methods. The foundation of psychological research is evidence-based, relying heavily on the scientific method to derive and validate knowledge. This structured approach ensures that findings are reliable, valid, and applicable to broader contexts.
The scientific method in psychology involves six critical steps: making observations, formulating hypotheses, conducting tests, analyzing...
The scientific method in psychology involves six critical steps: making observations, formulating hypotheses, conducting tests, analyzing...
4.0K
01:12Average Velocity
24.3K
To calculate the other physical quantities in kinematics, we must introduce the time variable. The time variable allows us not only to state the position of the object during its motion, but also how fast it is moving. The speed at which an object is moving is given by the rate at which the position changes with time. For each position xi, we assign a particular time ti. If the details of the motion at each instant are not important, the rate is usually expressed as the average velocity. This...
24.3K
01:17Average Value of a Function
70
The average value of a function over a closed interval can be interpreted geometrically as the height of a rectangle whose area equals the net area under the curve across that interval. This net area accounts for both positive and negative contributions of the function, providing a single representative value that reflects the function’s overall behaviorA practical illustration of this idea arises when monitoring the temperature inside a greenhouse over a twenty-four-hour period. Although...
70