Markers of oil exposure in cold-water benthic environments: Insights and challenges from a study with echinoderms

In spite of increasing naval activities and petroleum exploration in cold environments, there is currently a paucity of tools available to monitor oil contamination in boreal marine life, especially in sedentary (non-fish) species that dominate benthic communities. This research aimed to identify biotic sources of variation in biomarkers using subarctic echinoderms, and to identify suitable biomarkers of their exposure to hydrocarbons. The focal species included the sea star Asterias rubens, the brittle star Ophiopholis aculeata, the sea urchin Strongylocentrotus droebachiensis, and the sea cucumber Cucumaria frondosa, which are among the most abundant echinoderms in the North Atlantic and Arctic Oceans. The latter two species are also commercially exploited. A series of 96-h acute exposures of the water-accommodating fraction (WAF) of used lubricating oil (ULO) were performed in different seasons (i.e. distinct reproductive stages). Digestive and reproductive tissues were analyzed for baseline and response levels of glutathione peroxidase (GPx) and ethoxyresorufin-O-deethylase (EROD). GPx activity was detected in the pyloric caecum, stomach, and gonad of sea stars, the intestine and gonad of sea cucumbers, and the gonad of brittle stars and sea urchins. No seasonal variation in baseline GPx activity occurred. Upon exposure to the ULO WAF, sex-based differences were elicited in the GPx activity of sea star stomachs (lower in females than males). EROD activity was present in the pyloric caeca of sea stars, and the gonads of brittle stars and sea urchins. An interaction between season and sex on baseline EROD activity was measured in the gonads of sea urchins. Ovaries exhibited significant seasonal variation in EROD activity and had greater activity than testes during the spawning and post-spawning seasons. Seasonal variation in EROD activity also occurred in sea star pyloric caeca and brittle star gonads. Furthermore, testes of sea urchins exposed to the ULO WAF exhibited suppressed EROD activity compared to baseline levels. The nearly universal presence of GPx activity highlights its potential as a useful biomarker, while EROD activity was much more limited. Findings suggest a complex relationship between temporal and biotic factors on both the baseline and response levels of enzymatic activity, emphasizing the need to consider sex and sampling season in studies of biomarkers of hydrocarbon exposure in boreal indicator species that display annual reproductive cycles.