Human fetal lymphocytes require T cell growth factors for cytotoxic responses

Lymphocytes isolated from the blood of 17 human fetuses, varying in gestational age between 16 and 26 weeks, were tested for their capacity to generate specific cytotoxic cells after mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) with allogeneic cells in the presence or absence of exogenous T cell growth factor (TCGF). Blood cells from seven fetuses, distributed throughout the age range, failed to generate cytotoxic cells even when TCGF was added in MLC, whereas six others gave positive responses but only when exogenous TCGF was present during the sensitisation phase. The maturation induced in the latter was not caused solely by a direct, non-specific effect of the TCGF, for control responder cells incubated with TCGF in the absence of allogeneic stimulator cells always responded less strongly or not at all. Fetal blood lymphocytes from the remaining four fetuses gave significant cytotoxic responses that were not augmented by TCGF. It is concluded that there can be a clear dichotomy between proliferative and cytotoxic responses to alloantigens and that the inability of human fetal blood lymphocytes to mount cytotoxic responses at this stage of development might be due to deficiencies in helper cells, cytotoxic precursors or both. For three fetuses it was possible to study, additionally, cytotoxic responses of spleen, liver and thymus with and without TCGF. None of them made specific responses even when TCGF was added, though cells from two spleens and one thymus responded directly to TCGF. To ascertain whether the absence of cytotoxic responses might have been caused by a failure of blood, spleen, thymus or liver cells to proliferate, their mixed lymphocyte reactivity, as detected by the uptake of 3H-thymidine, was studied without exogenous TCGF. Whereas thymus cells from only one of five fetuses responded, cells from all other tissues (including blood) responded consistently.