Critical quality evaluation of network meta-analyses in dental care
1Department of Pediatric Dentistry and Institute of Oral Bioscience, School of Dentistry, Chonbuk National University, Jeonju, Republic of Korea.
Objective:
Network meta-analysis (NMA) is a new method to compare the effects of multiple treatments in dental care. We examined whether published NMA follow the key methodological reporting recommendations, the PRISMA Extension Statement.
Design:
Collection of published systematic reviews with NMA in dental care DATA SOURCES: MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Web of Science searched from inception to May 1, 2017.
Study Selection:
All NMA published in dental journals comparing the clinical efficacy of three or more interventions with and without closed loops.
Data Extraction And Synthesis:
NMA reporting was assessed according to the PRISMA Extension checklist. We assessed the reporting of general components (27 items) and key NMA methodological components (5 new items, S 1-5) of the systematic review process of NMA in dental care.
Results:
Among 85 identified articles, 21 NMA (16 used the Bayesian statistical approach, and 5 the frequentist approach) were included. Overall, among 21 articles, 15 (71%) reports of NMA in dental care did not describe in detail the network regarding S1-5 based on the PRISMA Extension. Problem areas include exploring the geometry of the network (S1), assessment of insistency (S2) in the method section, presentation of network structure (S3), summary of network geometry (S4), exploration for inconsistency (S5) in the result section, risk of bias across studies, protocol registrations, and additional analysis.
Conclusions:
The quality of NMA reporting was low in the dental field. An NMA with inadequate reporting reduces the end-user's confidence on the quality of the reported results. The PRISMA Extension guideline is relatively new and should be used more extensively to improve reporting practices in the field of dental care.
More Related Videos
07:58Behavioral and Network Pharmacology-Based Analyses for the Traditional Mongolian Medicine Zadi-5 in a Rat Model of Depression
Published on: February 24, 2023
04:34Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness and Safety of Shugan Jieyu Capsules for the Treatment of Insomnia
Published on: February 17, 2023
Related Concept Videos
02:26Protein Networks
These interactions can be represented through maps depicting protein-protein interaction networks, represented as nodes and edges. Nodes are circles that are representative of a protein,...
01:16Critical Region, Critical Values and Significance Level
In hypothesis testing, a sample statistic is converted to a test statistic using z, t, or chi-square distribution. A critical region is an area under the curve in probability distributions demarcated by the critical value. When the test statistic falls in this region, it suggests that the null hypothesis must be rejected. As this region contains all those values of the...
01:09Directing Effect of Substituents: meta-Directing Groups
01:31Critical Values
02:18Network Covalent Solids
To break or to melt a covalent network solid, covalent bonds must be broken. Because covalent bonds are relatively strong, covalent network solids are typically...
01:24Critical Thinking I