Implementation of a Novel Conference Series on Clinical Practice Variations Provides an Opportunity for Constructive...

Although evidence-based medicine (EBM) is routinely used to guide management in the emergency department, there is still considerable variation in clinical practice. Trainees may not fully appreciate the reasons for these clinical practice variations (CPVs) and may find it frustrating when they encounter them. We used areas of CPV among our faculty as the basis for resident educational sessions and assessed the perceived utility of these sessions.

Topics were identified when residents noticed significant variability among the faculty in their management of particular clinical presentations. Sessions were conducted by facilitator-led reviews of EBM guidelines, by faculty panel discussions of their management rationale where EBM guidelines are not available, or by pro-con debates. Residents were surveyed after the initial sessions to assess the utility of this series and changes in their understanding of CPV.

There was a 72% response rate. The percentage of residents who were frustrated with CPV decreased from 64% to 35%; the percentage who felt that the presence of CPV enhanced their learning increased from 19% to 48%. Sixty-five percent felt that the educational series contributed to decreased frustration, 77% felt that the sessions helped them understand why CPV occurs, and 93% felt that they helped their overall learning.

Explicit discussion and exploration of CPV in an educational setting can provide multiple benefits. Trainees may gain a better understanding of why CPV occurs and of the rationale behind practice variations. Faculty may benefit from analyzing CPV to determine whether these truly represent the "art of medicine."