The impact of surgical manipulation on lower lateral cartilage stiffness

Cephalic trimming of the alar (or lower lateral) cartilage may cause weakening leading to external nasal valve collapse. Numerous methods have been proposed to combat this weakening in order to maintain lateral crural stiffness. The purpose of this study was to quantify the effect of mucosal stripping, cephalic trimming, cephalic turn-in flap, and lateral crural strut grafting on lateral crural stiffness.

In situ cyclic compressive loading was performed on eight lateral crura in 4 fresh frozen cadaveric specimens. Testing was performed on the unaltered degloved cartilage (intact) and following each of the following interventions: mucosal stripping, cephalic turn-in flap, cephalic trimming, and lateral crural strut grafting. Linear regression of the generated force-displacement curves was used to calculate stiffness. Each intervention was compared to the intact cartilage.

Alar cartilage of all of the specimens demonstrated a linear response to compressive loading. Intact cartilage had a mean stiffness of 3.53 N/mm. Mucosal stripping and cephalic turn-in flaps yielded similar stiffness values to intact cartilage. Cephalic trimming reduced stiffness in all cases by a mean of 1.09 N/mm (p = 0.003). Lateral crural strut grafting significantly increased stiffness by a mean of 3.67 N/mm (p = 0.0001).

Cephalic trimming leads to decreased lateral crural stiffness in cadaveric specimens. Cephalic turn-in flaps restore pre-trimmed stiffness, and lateral crural strut grafting increases overall stiffness of the cartilage. These findings should be considered in patients undergoing rhinoplasty, particularly if there are concerns regarding potential external valve collapse.