Comment on "DNA damage is a pervasive cause of sequencing errors, directly confounding variant identification"

Chip Stewart1, Ignaty Leshchiner1, Julian Hess1

  • 1Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, MA 02124, USA.

Science (New York, N.Y.)
|September 29, 2018
PubMed

Insights

Sequencing artifacts from DNA damage can affect research findings. Previous studies, including The Cancer Genome Atlas, have already identified and addressed these DNA sequencing issues.

Area of Science:

  • Genomics
  • Molecular Biology
  • Bioinformatics

Background:

  • DNA damage during sample processing can introduce sequencing artifacts.
  • These artifacts may lead to erroneous conclusions in genetic studies.
  • Previous research has identified and mitigated similar artifacts.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To critically evaluate the findings presented by Chen et al. regarding DNA sequencing artifacts.
  • To address errors in the manuscript by Chen et al.
  • To highlight prior work on sequencing artifacts.

Main Methods:

  • Review of the manuscript by Chen et al.
  • Comparison with established protocols and findings from large-scale sequencing projects.
  • Analysis of DNA damage-induced sequencing errors.

Main Results:

  • The manuscript by Chen et al. contains factual errors.
  • The conclusions drawn by Chen et al. are not supported due to these errors.
  • The sequencing artifacts discussed were previously identified and managed.

Conclusions:

  • The findings by Chen et al. are flawed due to methodological errors and overlooked prior research.
  • The problem of DNA damage-induced sequencing artifacts is recognized and has been addressed in major genomics initiatives.
  • Researchers should be aware of existing literature on sequencing artifact mitigation.

Related Concept Videos

Nucleotide Excision Repair01:08

Nucleotide Excision Repair

Overview
Overview of DNA Repair02:25

Overview of DNA Repair

In order to be passed through generations, genomic DNA must be undamaged and error-free. However, every day, DNA in a cell undergoes several thousand to a million damaging events by natural causes and external factors. Ionizing radiation such as UV rays, free radicals produced during cellular respiration, and hydrolytic damage from metabolic reactions can alter the structure of DNA. Damages caused include single-base alteration, base dimerization, chain breaks, and cross-linkage.
Chemically...
Nucleotide Excision Repair01:08

Nucleotide Excision Repair

Overview
DNA Damage can Stall the Cell Cycle02:36

DNA Damage can Stall the Cell Cycle

In response to DNA damage, cells can pause the cell cycle to assess and repair the breaks. However, the cell must check the DNA at certain critical stages during the cell cycle. If the cell cycle pauses before DNA replication, the cells will contain twice the amount of DNA. On the other hand, if cells arrest after DNA replication but before mitosis, they will contain four times the normal amount of DNA. With a host of specialized proteins at their disposal,cells must use the right protein at...
Overview of DNA Repair02:25

Overview of DNA Repair

In order to be passed through generations, genomic DNA must be undamaged and error-free. However, every day, DNA in a cell undergoes several thousand to a million damaging events by natural causes and external factors. Ionizing radiation such as UV rays, free radicals produced during cellular respiration, and hydrolytic damage from metabolic reactions can alter the structure of DNA. Damages caused include single-base alteration, base dimerization, chain breaks, and cross-linkage.
Chemically...
Nucleotide Excision Repair01:38

Nucleotide Excision Repair

DNA Distortion and Damage
Cells are regularly exposed to mutagens—factors in the environment that can damage DNA and generate mutations. UV radiation is one of the most common mutagens and is estimated to introduce a significant number of changes in DNA. These include bends or kinks in the structure, which can block DNA replication or transcription. If these errors are not fixed, the damage can cause mutations, which in turn can result in cancer or disease depending on which sequences are...