Tone-in-noise detection deficits in elderly patients with clinically normal hearing

One of the most common complaints among the elderly is the inability to understand speech in noisy environments. In many cases, these deficits are due to age-related hearing loss; however, some of the elderly that have difficulty hearing in noise have clinically normal pure-tone thresholds. While speech in noise testing is informative, it fails to identify specific frequencies responsible for the speech processing deficit. Auditory neuropathy patients and animal models of hidden hearing loss suggest that tone-in-noise thresholds may provide frequency specific information for those patients who express difficulty, but have normal thresholds in quiet. Therefore, we aimed to determine if tone-in-noise thresholds could be a useful measure in detecting age-related hearing deficits, despite having normal audiometric thresholds.

We tested this hypothesis by measuring tone-in-noise thresholds in 11 Old (62.4 ± 5 years) and 21 Young (23.1 ± 2.2 years) patients with clinically normal thresholds. Tone thresholds were measured in a quite sound field, then in 20, 30 and 40 dB HL broadband noise.

Despite having normal hearing (thresholds ≤25 dB HL), the Old patients had significantly worse tone-in-noise thresholds than the Young patients at 0.125, 4, and 8 kHz. Linear regression analysis showed that the growth of masking in Old and Young patients was nearly identical at all frequencies. However, the amount of masking at low and high frequencies was typically 10-18 dB greater in the Old patients compared to the Young, except near 1 kHz. The frequency-dependent changes in masking are discussed in the context of a "line busy" model and temporal bone studies of auditory nerve fiber loss.