Related Experiment Video
Updated: Feb 3, 2026
An Experimental Analysis of Children's Ability to Provide a False Report about a Crime
Published on: May 3, 2016
How mandatory is the mandatory reporting of children at risk?
David Isaacs1,2,3, Philip N Britton1,2,3, Henry A Kilham2,3
1Department of Infectious Diseases and Microbiology, Children's Hospital at Westmead, New South Wales, Australia.
Insights
Mandatory reporting of child abuse requires careful consideration. A balanced approach, prioritizing maternal engagement and confidentiality, may yield better outcomes for children and families.
Area of Science:
- Medical Ethics
- Pediatrics
- Public Health
Background:
- Mandatory reporting of suspected child abuse is a long-standing policy.
- Quantitative studies on the effectiveness of mandatory reporting for child outcomes are lacking.
- Case scenarios highlight ethical dilemmas in balancing reporting with maternal confidentiality and engagement.
Purpose of the Study:
- To explore the complexities of mandatory reporting in maternal infection cases.
- To examine the potential impact of reporting on maternal engagement and child welfare.
- To advocate for a nuanced approach to reporting timing and collaboration with child protection services.
Main Methods:
- Case study analysis of two scenarios involving maternal tuberculosis (TB) and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV).
- Exploration of differing professional opinions on reporting obligations versus maintaining maternal confidentiality.
- Evaluation of alternative strategies focusing on enhanced communication before mandatory reporting.
Main Results:
- Deferred reporting in the TB case, coupled with intensive communication efforts, led to successful engagement.
- In the HIV case, collaboration with child protection allowed for conditional reporting based on communication outcomes.
- Both cases suggest that vigorous efforts to engage mothers can be effective.
Conclusions:
- A rigid adherence to mandatory reporting may not always serve the best interests of the child.
- A considered, collaborative approach with child protection services is advocated.
- Balancing legal obligations with pragmatic strategies can improve maternal engagement and child outcomes.
Abstract:
Although mandatory reporting of suspected child abuse was first introduced over 50 years ago, there are no quantitative studies addressing whether or not it achieves better outcomes for children. We report two cases of maternal infection, one with tuberculosis (TB) and one with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), where the mothers' failure to attend follow-up appointments raised the possibility of significant harm if their infants were infected. Some health professionals argued strongly that mandatory reporting meant the mothers should be reported to child protection authorities. Others argued that the risk was not critically imminent and an immediate report could seriously compromise maternal confidentiality, risked maternal disengagement and a worse outcome. An alternative was to make more vigorous efforts to contact the mothers and report only if these failed. In the TB case, reporting to child protection was deferred in favour of making more strenuous efforts at communication, which proved successful. In the HIV case, a case worker reported the case to child protection, but when the doctor contacted child protection authorities they agreed not to contact the mother unless the doctor's vigorous attempts to communicate with her failed. We do not advocate for breaking the law regarding mandatory reporting, but we do argue for a considered approach to the timing of reporting and for a collaborative approach with child protection services.
More Related Videos
Related Concept Videos
01:12Relative Risk
01:24Data Reporting and Recording
01:26Factors Affecting the Risk of Infection
The integrity and count of the white blood cells help the body resist pathogens and fight infection. When impaired, it reduces the body's resistance to pathogens. The acidic pH levels of the gastrointestinal, genitourinary tracts, and skin...
01:25Types of Reports I: Hands-off Report
Following are the key components and categories of hand-off reports:
Purpose and Process:
01:21Types of Reports II: Incident or Occurrence Report
Purposes:
In the healthcare industry, reports play a crucial role in documenting incidents within an agency. The primary objective of these reports is to ensure patient safety, uphold the...
01:29Drug Dosing: Infants and Children