Protein adsorption to poly(ethylenimine)-modified sepharose FF: VII. Complicated effects of pH

Previously, we have studied protein adsorption behaviors on a series of poly(ethylenimine) (PEI)-grafted Sepharose FF, and a critical ionic capacity of PEI-grafted resins was observed, above which both protein adsorption capacity (q) and effective pore diffusivity (D_e) increased drastically. Moreover, reducing the charge density of the PEI-grafted resins from an ionic capacity of 740 mmol/L (FF-PEI-L740) to 440 mmol/L (FF-PEI-R440) by neutralization of the amino groups of PEI chains with sodium acetate brought out a three-fold increase of D_e value at pH 8. In this work, FF-PEI-L740 and FF-PEI-R440 were selected to investigate the complicated effects of pH on protein adsorption behavior using bovine serum albumin (BSA) as the model protein. It was found that, for FF-PEI-L740, both the q and D_e values decreased significantly when pH decreased from 9 to 5.5, and then increased dramatically at pH 5, and finally decreased remarkably at pH 4.5. The results were considered due to the following causes: The decrease of pH from 9 to 5.5 led to a greatly increased electrostatic repulsion between the PEI chains due to the increased dissociation degree of PEI, which caused the increase in steric hindrance effects and decrease in the bound protein transport by chain delivery. At pH 5, which was near the pI of BSA (∼4.9), the presence of few protein charges greatly decreased the electrostatic hindrance effect on protein transport and the high charge density of FF-PEI-L740 provided extensively accessible binding sites and facilitated the happening of chain delivery as well. At pH 4.5, the net charge of BSA shifted to positive, likely charged with PEI, so the overall electrostatic repulsion greatly hindered protein uptake. For FF-PEI-R440, whose charge density was much lower than FF-PEI-L740, its q and D_e values even increased mildly when pH decreased from 8 to 5.5, because its slightly-increased charge density did not cause much increased electrostatic and steric hindrance effects but provided more binding sites for protein adsorption. At pH 5, the few charges of BSA and the low charge density of FF-PEI-R440 could not afford enough electrostatic interaction for protein binding, resulting in significantly decreased q and D_e values. Besides, column breakthrough experiments revealed that FF-PEI-R440 kept high dynamic binding capacity (DBC) (>120 mg/mL) at pH 5.5-8, while FF-PEI-L740 offered high DBC (>80 mg/mL) at pH 5, 7 and 8 with a higher salt concentration (100 mmol/L NaCl). These findings demonstrated the excellence of FF-PEI-L740 and FF-PEI-R440 in different conditions, and would help in the design and selection of suitable resins for high-performance protein chromatography.