Impact on long-term cardiovascular outcomes of different cardiac resynchronization therapy response criteria
Inês Rodrigues1, Ana Abreu1, Mário Oliveira1
1Cardiology Department, Hospital de Santa Marta, Centro Hospitalar de Lisboa Central, Lisbon, Portugal.
Insights
Defining response to cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) is crucial. Few criteria predict cardiac event-free survival, highlighting the need for standardized definitions in CRT studies.
Area of Science:
- Cardiology
- Clinical Trials
- Heart Failure Management
Background:
- Cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) is a treatment for heart failure.
- There is a lack of consensus on how to define patient response to CRT.
- Existing response criteria may not reliably predict clinical outcomes.
Purpose of the Study:
- To evaluate the predictive value of various CRT response criteria for cardiac event-free survival.
- To assess the agreement between different CRT response criteria.
- To identify reliable indicators of CRT success.
Main Methods:
- Secondary analysis of the BETTER-HF trial data.
- Eleven different response criteria were applied to patients six months post-CRT.
- Cox regression and Cohen's kappa were used to assess predictive value and agreement.
Main Results:
- Only five of eleven criteria predicted event-free survival.
- Reduced NYHA class (≥1) and increased LVEF (≥15%) were significant predictors.
- Agreement between response criteria was generally poor.
Conclusions:
- Many current CRT response criteria lack predictive power for clinical outcomes.
- Poor agreement among criteria hinders consistent patient assessment.
- Establishing a consensus definition for CRT response is essential for standardizing research and clinical practice.
Introduction:
There is a lack of consensus on the definition of response to cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT), and it is not clear which response criteria have most influence on cardiac event-free survival.
Objectives:
To assess the predictive value of various response criteria in patients undergoing CRT and the agreement between them.
Methods:
We performed a secondary analysis of the BETTER-HF trial. Patient response was classified at six months after CRT according to eleven criteria used in previous trials. The predictive value of response criteria for survival free from mortality, cardiac transplantation and heart failure hospitalization was assessed by Cox regression analysis. Agreement between the different response criteria was assessed using Cohen's kappa (κ).
Results:
A total of 115 patients were followed for a mean of 25 months. During follow-up, 15 deaths occurred (13%) and 29 patients had at least one adverse cardiac event (25%). Only five of the eleven response criteria were predictors of event-free survival. The most powerful isolated clinical and echocardiographic predictors were a reduction of ≥1 NYHA functional class (HR 0.39 for responders; 95% CI 0.18-0.83, p=0.014) and an increase of at least 15% in left ventricular ejection fraction (HR 0.43, 95% CI 0.20-0.90, p=0.024), respectively. Agreement between the different response criteria was poor.
Conclusions:
Most currently used response criteria do not predict clinical outcomes and have poor agreement. It is essential to establish a consensus on the definition of CRT response in order to standardize studies.
More Related Videos
Related Concept Videos
Exercise and Cardiovascular Response
Light to moderate physical activity initiates a series of interconnected responses in the body. The heart rate modestly increases in anticipation of the workout, followed by widespread vasodilation as oxygen consumption by skeletal muscles increases. This results in decreased peripheral resistance, increased capillary blood flow, and accelerated...
Blood Studies for Cardiovascular System I: Cardiac Biomarkers
The essential diagnostic tools for detecting myocardial necrosis and monitoring individuals suspected of having acute coronary syndrome (ACS) include:
Troponins
Troponins, particularly cardiac troponins I and T, are the most precise and sensitive markers of myocardial injury. They are detectable within 4-6 hours of myocardial injury and remain...
Criteria for Causality: Bradford Hill Criteria - II
Criteria for Causality: Bradford Hill Criteria - I
Blood Studies for Cardiovascular System II: CRP, Hcy, and Cardiac Natriuretic Peptide Markers
These markers indicate stress or strain on the heart muscle:
Natriuretic Peptides (BNP)
Cardiac myocytes produce these hormones in response to ventricular stretching...
Long-term Depression


