Perceived Benefits, Risks, and Utility of Newborn Genomic Sequencing in the BabySeq Project

Stacey Pereira1, Jill Oliver Robinson1, Amanda M Gutierrez1

  • 1Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas.

Pediatrics
|January 3, 2019
PubMed

Insights

Parents and clinicians show varied confidence in genomic sequencing (GS) for newborns compared to newborn screening (NBS). While both see benefits, parents perceive a more favorable risk-benefit ratio for GS than clinicians do.

Area of Science:

  • Genomics
  • Pediatrics
  • Bioethics

Background:

  • Interest is growing in using genomic sequencing (GS) for newborn clinical care.
  • Newborn screening (NBS) is the current standard for genetic disorder detection in infants.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To explore parents' and clinicians' attitudes toward newborn genomic sequencing (GS).
  • To compare perceptions of risks, benefits, and utility of GS versus newborn screening (NBS) in newborns.

Main Methods:

  • The BabySeq Project, a randomized controlled trial, surveyed 493 parents and 144 clinicians.
  • Attitudes and perceived risks/benefits of NBS and GS were assessed via baseline surveys.
  • Open-ended responses regarding risks and benefits were thematically categorized.

Main Results:

  • Most parents (71%) and clinicians (51%) agreed GS has health benefits.
  • Parents perceived greater benefits and fewer risks of GS compared to clinicians.
  • Clinicians expressed stronger concerns about privacy and discrimination risks associated with GS.

Conclusions:

  • Parents and clinicians exhibit less confidence in GS than NBS.
  • Parents hold a more optimistic view of GS's risk-benefit ratio than clinicians.
  • Clinicians should recognize that parental optimism may stem from perceived benefits beyond direct clinical utility.
Abstract

Related Concept Videos

Genomics02:02

Genomics

Genomics is the science of genomes: it is the study of all the genetic material of an organism. In humans, the genome consists of information carried in 23 pairs of chromosomes in the nucleus, as well as mitochondrial DNA. In genomics, both coding and non-coding DNA is sequenced and analyzed. Genomics allows a better understanding of all living things, their evolution, and their diversity. It has a myriad of uses: for example, to build phylogenetic trees, to improve productivity and...
40.6K
Benefits of Self-Esteem01:25

Benefits of Self-Esteem

Self-esteem—an individual's overall evaluation of their worth—plays a complex role in psychological functioning and well-being. It is often associated with many positive traits, such as confidence, optimism, and perseverance. Individuals with high self-esteem typically experience better sleep, manage peer pressure more effectively, and report greater life satisfaction. Conversely, low self-esteem has been consistently linked with increased risks of depression, anxiety, and poor...
197
Perceiving Loudness, Pitch, and Location01:21

Perceiving Loudness, Pitch, and Location

The human brain perceives pitch through two primary mechanisms reflected in place theory and frequency theory. Each mechanism describes how sound waves are interpreted as specific pitches by the brain, offering insights into the intricate processes of auditory perception.
Place theory, or place coding, suggests that different pitches are heard because various sound waves activate specific locations along the cochlea's basilar membrane. The brain determines the pitch of a sound by...
985
Fischer Projections02:18

Fischer Projections

Learning to draw Fischer projections of molecules and understanding their relevance plays a crucial role in the visual depiction of organic molecules. A Fischer projection is a two-dimensional projection on a planar surface to simplify the three-dimensional wedge–dash representation of molecules. This is especially helpful in the case of molecules with multiple chiral centers that can be difficult to draw. Here, all the bonds of interest are represented as horizontal or vertical lines. While...
16.5K
Genomic Imprinting and Inheritance02:30

Genomic Imprinting and Inheritance

Diploid organisms inherit genetic material through chromosomes from both parents. Copies of the same gene are known as alleles. In most cases, both alleles are simultaneously expressed and allow various cellular processes to function optimally. If one of the alleles is missing or mutated, the expression of the other allele can compensate; however, this is not true for all genes.
The expression of some genes depends on which parent passed the gene to the offspring, through a phenomenon known as...
37.2K
Newman Projections02:06

Newman Projections

Different notations are used to represent the three-dimensional structure of molecules on two-dimensional surfaces. One of the most commonly used representations is the dash-wedge formula. The dashed wedges, solid wedges, and the plane lines indicate the groups situated behind the plane, coming out of the plane, and in the plane, respectively.
The organic molecules rotate across the single bonds leading to numerous temporary three-dimensional structures of varying energy known as...
20.9K