Ion mobility spectrometers and electron capture detector - A comparison of detection capabilities

Electron capture detectors (ECDs) and detectors used in ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) have been successfully used for the detection of numerous compounds including hazardous substances. The general principles of their operations are similar and based on sample component ionization and measurement of the signal using the differences in the mobility of electric charge carriers. Differences in sensitivity result from various parameters of these instruments. Value of electric field intensity in ionic reactors have an influence on ionization process. The main goal of the performed tests was to compare the analytical properties of ECD and two types of IMS detectors: a drift tube spectrometer (DT IMS) and a differential mobility spectrometer (DMS). In the work performed, the efficiency of ionization and the response of detectors to selected analytes were compared. ECD, DT IMS and DMS were equipped with 63-Ni radioactive sources. Analytes have been ionized via electron capture process or dissociative electron transfer. Results obtained for oxygen and chloro-substituted organic compounds (carbon tetrachloride, benzyl chloride, chloroform, 2-chloroethyl ethyl sulfide) were used to calculate the relative signal and to compare the ionization efficiency for three detectors. The phenomena observed experimentally were related to energy dependencies and electron capture cross-sections of analytes. The efficiency of ionization in DT IMS was also compared for electron capture when nitrogen was used as the carrier gas, and when the ionization process was based on the collisions of the analyte molecules with the O₂^- with the use of air.