The Anderson-Josephson quantum dot-a theory perspective

Recent progress in nanoscale manufacturing has allowed to experimentally investigate quantum dots coupled to two superconducting leads in controlled and tunable setups. The equilibrium Josephson current was measured in on-chip superconducting quantum interference devices, and subgap states were investigated using weakly coupled metallic leads for spectroscopy. This has reinstated two 'classic' problems on the agenda of theoretical condensed matter physics: (1) the Josephson effect and (2) quantum spins in superconductors. The relevance of the former is obvious as the barrier, which separates the two superconductors in a standard Josephson junction, is merely replaced by the quantum dot with well separated energy levels. For odd filling of the dot it acts as a quantum mechanical spin-1/2 and thereby the relevance of the latter becomes apparent also. For normal conducting leads and at odd dot filling the Kondo effect strongly modifies the transport properties as can, e.g. be studied within the Anderson model. One can expect the same for superconducting leads, and in certain parameter regimes remnants of Kondo physics, i.e. strong electronic correlations, will affect the Josephson current. In this topical review, we discuss the status of the theoretical understanding of the Anderson-Josephson quantum dot in equilibrium, mainly focusing on the Josephson current. We introduce a minimal model consisting of a dot which can only host a single spin-up and a single spin-down electron repelling each other by a local Coulomb interaction. The dot is tunnel-coupled to two superconducting leads as described by the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer Hamiltonian. This model was investigated using a variety of methods, some capturing aspects of Kondo physics, while others failing in this respect. We briefly review this. The model shows a first order level-crossing quantum phase transition when varying any parameter, provided that the others are within appropriate ranges. At vanishing temperature it leads to a jump of the Josephson current. To study the qualitative behavior of the phase diagram, or the Josephson current, several of the methods can be used. However, for a quantitative description, elaborate quantum many-body methods must be employed. We show that a quantitative agreement between accurate results obtained for the simple model and measurements of the current can be reached. This confirms that the experiments reveal the finite temperature signatures of the zero temperature transition. In addition, we consider two examples of more complex dot geometries, which might be experimentally realized in the near future. The first is characterized by the interplay of the above level-crossing physics and the Fano effect, and the second by the interplay of superconductivity and almost degenerate singlet and triplet two-body states.