Chemonucleolysis or discectomy? Results of a randomized multicentre trial in patients with a herniated lumbar...

A randomized trial was carried out to compare the results of discectomy and chemonucleolysis in 151 patients, suffering from lumbar disc herniation L4-L5 or L5-S1. All patients fulfilled strict entry criteria. Seventy eight patients underwent surgical discectomy, 73 were treated with chemonucleolysis. Within one year of follow-up 18 patients (25%) required surgery after chemonucleolysis, whereas 2 patients (3%) in the surgery group underwent re-operation. Increase of radicular pain within 30 days after treatment was encountered in 16 patients (22%) in the chemonucleolysis group, as compared to none in the surgery group. The results of open surgery after preceding chemonucleolysis was successful in 44% and unsuccessful in 56%. The final result of chemonucleolysis, including second treatment, was still slightly less favourable (73%) the result of primary surgery (79%).