Optimal age for screening colonoscopy: a modeling study

Recent guidelines on colorectal cancer (CRC) screening recommend starting screening earlier than before. We performed a simulation study to examine and compare the optimal ages to have once-only screening colonoscopy and repeated colonoscopies.

A Markov model was set up using data from the German national screening colonoscopy registry to simulate the natural history of the adenoma-carcinoma process. CRC deaths and years of potential life lost (YPLL) for a hypothetical unscreened 50-year-old German population were estimated for a single screening colonoscopy or 2 or 3 screening colonoscopies with 10-year intervals at various ages.

One single screening colonoscopy performed between 50 and 65 years of age was expected to reduce CRC death by 49% to 69% and YPLL by 51% to 68%. An inverted U-shaped association was found between screening age and proportion of CRC deaths or YPLL prevented. The optimal age for once-only colonoscopy that yielded the highest reductions in YPLL was around 54 years for men and 56 years for women. Estimates were approximately 6 to 8 years higher when proportions of CRC deaths prevented were examined. For 2 or 3 screening colonoscopies, the optimal starting age fell to around 50 years or even younger for both genders.

Based on the YPLL estimates, in a high CRC incidence and high life expectancy country like Germany, the optimal age for once-only screening colonoscopy is around 55 years and possibly slightly younger for men than for women. When 2 or more screening colonoscopies are offered with 10-year intervals, screening should start at age 50 at the latest or possibly even younger for both genders.