Nonbeneficial Intensive Care: Misalignments Between Provider Assessments of Benefit and Use of Invasive Treatments

The purpose of this study was to examine how frequently invasive intensive care unit (ICU) treatments are delivered to critically ill patients despite clinicians' impressions that ICU care may be nonbeneficial.

Patients admitted to the medical ICU of an academic public hospital were prospectively categorized according to guidelines from the Society of Critical Care Medicine which classifies patients based on severity of illness and likelihood of recovery (categories 1-4). Clinical data and use of ICU treatments in patients with high (category 1) and low (category 3) likelihoods of benefit were collected by chart review. Multivariable regression analyses examined associations between use of invasive treatments and patient categories, and clinical factors associated with receiving invasive ICU treatments despite low likelihood of benefit.

There were 533 patients (369 in category 1 and 164 in category 3) in the study. A total of 19.8%, 29.9%, and 28.9% of patient-days on mechanical ventilation, vasopressors, and renal replacement therapy, respectively, were delivered to patients who were considered unlikely to benefit from ICU treatments (category 3) and ultimately did not survive hospitalization. These patients also received 35.2% of cardiopulmonary resuscitation attempts and 22.6% of central venous catheter placements. Clinicians' impressions of likelihood of benefit (category 1 vs 3) were not associated with odds of receiving invasive ICU treatments. Clinical characteristics associated with greater odds of receiving potentially nonbeneficial treatments included older age, presence of dementia or malignancy, and higher Acute Physiologic Assessment and Chronic Health Evaluation score.

Invasive ICU treatments are frequently delivered to patients who are not expected to benefit from ICU care and die during hospitalization. These findings highlight the need to improve utilization of ICU services among patients with advanced medical illnesses.