Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jan 28, 2026

A Simple Planting Technique for Re-establishing Trees Where Frequent Inundation Occurs
Published on: January 26, 2018
Comparison of non-Cochrane systematic reviews and their published protocols: differences occurred frequently but were
Nadja Koensgen1, Tanja Rombey1, Katharina Allers2
1Faculty of Health, School of Medicine, Institute for Research in Operative Medicine, Witten/Herdecke University, Ostmerheimer Str. 200, 51109 Cologne, Germany.
Objective:
To quantify the prevalence of differences in the reported methods between non-Cochrane systematic reviews (SRs) and their protocols and the extent to which these were reported and explained.
Study Design And Setting:
We searched MEDLINE and Embase to identify protocols of non-Cochrane SRs published in 2012 and 2013. Using various methods, we searched for their corresponding SRs up to December 2016. The SRs and protocols were compared with respect to the methods-related "Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic review and Meta-Analysis Protocols" (PRISMA-P).
Results:
We included 80 SRs and their protocols. Almost all SRs (92.5%) differed from their protocols in at least one of the methods-related PRISMA-P items (no. 7-17) and their subcategories. Half the SRs (48.8%) had a major difference in at least one item. On average, each SR differed from its protocol in 3.2 items, of which one comprised a major difference. Only 10% of all differences were reported in the SR, two-thirds with an explanation (7.0% in total).
Conclusion:
The reporting quality and transparency of non-Cochrane SRs requires further improvement. Authors should report and explain all important changes made to the protocol in the SR publication. The updated PRISMA statement should include guidance regarding this matter.
Related Concept Videos
Cochran's Q Test
Review and Preview
Percentiles are a type of fractile that partition data into...
Review and Preview
Regulation of Expression Occurs at Multiple Steps
Transcription results in the generation of precursor (pre-mRNA) that consists of both exons and introns, which needs further processing before being translated to a...
Regulation of Expression Occurs at Multiple Steps
Kinetic Molecular Theory and Gas Laws Explain Properties of Gas Molecules
