An income over feed cost nutritional grouping strategy

This study introduces a new nutritional grouping method, OptiGroup, which maximizes milk income over feed cost (IOFC) using a mixed-integer nonlinear programming optimization algorithm. Analyses compared the OptiGroup with the cluster method, the current state-of-the-art nutritional grouping technique. Analyses were performed using cow-level data from 7 Wisconsin dairy farms. Consistently, the OptiGroup and the cluster were constrained to group cows simultaneously into 2 (low and high nutrient requirements) and 3 (low, medium, and high nutrient requirements) same-size groups. Each diet satisfied the net energy (NE_L) and crude protein (CP) requirements of approximately 83% of the cows in each group by using lead factors based on nutrient density. A control treatment (1-group scenario) was used as a baseline for comparisons. The IOFC, dietary nutrient densities (NE_L and CP), and dry matter intake with both methods were computed and compared. The percentage of cows grouped differently and the percentages of primiparous cows and late-lactation (>200 d in milk) cows in each group were also analyzed. Results were as follows: (1) average extra IOFC of $8/cow per yr (2-group) and $12/cow per yr (3-group) by switching from cluster to OptiGroup method; (2) difference between dietary nutrient densities of the groups were reduced under OptiGroup method compared with cluster (i.e., NE_L differences in 2 groups were 0.20 Mcal/kg for the cluster vs. 0.11 Mcal/kg for OptiGroup); (3) dry matter intake decreased with increasing group numbers within a grouping method, and decreased from cluster to OptiGroup method with constant group numbers; (4) percentage of primiparous cows was greater in the low group of cluster and in the high group of OptiGroup; and (5) proportion of late-lactation cows tended to be greater in the low group in both grouping strategies. Results indicated that the OptiGroup performed economically better than the cluster because of nutrient savings, even with high feed cost conditions. This study offers a new nutritional grouping paradigm, which could improve herd management on dairy farms. However, animal trials are needed to validate this new nutritional grouping method under farm conditions.