Palliation of Functionally Single Ventricle Patients in Sub-Saharan Africa-Is It Justifiable?
Frank Edwin1,2
11 Department of Surgery, University of Health and Allied Sciences, Ho, Ghana.
Insights
Limited resources in sub-Saharan Africa impact pediatric cardiac care. Cost-effectiveness analysis alone is insufficient for prioritizing treatment for children with single ventricle heart defects, as it overlooks public values.
Area of Science:
- Public Health
- Pediatric Cardiology
- Health Economics
Background:
- Sub-Saharan African nations face significant resource limitations affecting comprehensive pediatric cardiac care.
- Children with functionally single ventricle often receive low priority in healthcare policy due to cost-effectiveness considerations.
Purpose of the Study:
- To examine the criteria used by policymakers and the public in prioritizing healthcare, specifically for single ventricle palliation in sub-Saharan Africa.
- To critique the sole reliance on cost-effectiveness analysis for health-care priority setting in resource-limited settings.
Main Methods:
- This is a commentary, not an empirical study.
- It analyzes the ethical and societal implications of using cost-effectiveness as the primary decision-making tool.
Main Results:
- Cost-effectiveness analysis may exclude treatments for conditions with high treatment costs, such as single ventricle palliation.
- Decisions based solely on cost-effectiveness may not align with public values and ethical considerations.
Conclusions:
- Healthcare priority setting in sub-Saharan Africa requires a broader set of criteria beyond cost-effectiveness.
- Public acceptability and ethical considerations are crucial when making decisions about pediatric cardiac interventions for single ventricle patients.
Abstract:
Resource constraints in many sub-Saharan African countries undermine efforts to provide the full spectrum of pediatric cardiology and cardiac surgery. Palliation of the child born with functionally single ventricle is the lowest priority for policymakers when viewed from the perspective of cost-effectiveness. This commentary focuses on the relative importance of different criteria that policymakers and the general public consider important in setting health-care priorities as it relates to palliation of the patient with functionally single ventricle in sub-Saharan Africa. It argues the position that cost-effectiveness analysis tends to exclude those with high cost-to-treat illness, and decisions made on that basis alone are not acceptable to the general population on whose behalf those decisions are made.
More Related Videos
Related Concept Videos
Anatomy of the Brain: Ventricles
Functional Groups
Functional Groups
Patient-centered Care
Functionalism
James envisioned psychology's...
Fruit Development, Structure, and Function


