Potential predatory journals are colonizing the ICMJE recommendations list of followers

R Dal-Ré1, A Marušić

  • 1Health Research Institute-Fundación Jiménez Díaz University Hospital, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Avda Reyes Católicos 2, E-28040 Madrid, Spain.

Abstract

Insights

Predatory journals are present on the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors Recommendations (ICMJE-R) list. Reevaluating journals and removing predatory ones is crucial to prevent misleading authors.

Area of Science:

  • Medical ethics
  • Scholarly publishing
  • Bibliometrics

Background:

  • Concerns exist regarding predatory journals leveraging the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors Recommendations (ICMJE-R) list for legitimacy.
  • An assessment was conducted to identify potential predatory journals within the ICMJE-R follower list and evaluate their adherence to ICMJE recommendations.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To determine the prevalence of predatory journals among ICMJE Recommendations (ICMJE-R) followers.
  • To assess the adherence of these journals to established ICMJE recommendations.

Main Methods:

  • A random sample of 350 journals was selected from the estimated 3,100-3,200 biomedical journals listed as ICMJE-R followers.
  • Data on adherence to six ICMJE-R policies, publisher details, and article processing charges were collected from journal websites.

Main Results:

  • Thirty-one percent of sampled journals were identified as potentially predatory, with 94% listed between 2014-2018.
  • Adherence to ICMJE policies was infrequent, with only 7% meeting trial registration requirements.
  • Article processing charge information was unavailable for 22% of journals.

Conclusions:

  • Predatory journals should be removed from the ICMJE-R list to prevent misleading researchers.
  • A reevaluation of ICMJE-R following journals using predefined criteria is necessary.

Related Concept Videos

Journal Bearings01:23

Journal Bearings

Journal bearings are mechanical components that support and provide lateral stability to rotating shafts and axles. They are crucial in reducing friction, wear, and vibration in machinery such as engines, turbines, and pumps. The principle behind journal bearings is forming a thin lubricant film between the bearing surface and the rotating shaft, which minimizes direct contact and reduces frictional forces.
To better understand the concept of journal bearings, consider a rope winch with dry or...
1.1K
The Colonization of Land02:22

The Colonization of Land

Changes in the environment of the early Earth drove the evolution of organisms. As prokaryotic organisms in the oceans began to photosynthesize, they produced oxygen. Eventually, oxygen saturated the oceans and entered the air, resulting in an increase in atmospheric oxygen concentration, known as the oxygen revolution approximately 2.3 billion years ago. Therefore, organisms that could use oxygen for cellular respiration had an advantage. More than 1.5 years ago, eukaryotic cells and...
37.6K
Potential Energy00:52

Potential Energy

The energy stored by a structure and location of matter in space is called potential energy. For instance, raising a kettlebell changes its spatial location and increases its potential energy. Similarly, a stretched rubber band contains potential energy which, under certain conditions, can be converted into other forms of energy, such as kinetic energy.
Chemical bonds that form attractive forces between atoms also contain potential energy, called chemical energy. When a chemical reaction...
42.7K
Potential Energy01:09

Potential Energy

A conservative force, such as a gravitational or elastic force, gives the body the capacity to do work. This capacity, measured as the potential energy, depends on the body's location or “position” relative to a fixed reference position or datum. The gravitational potential energy is considered zero at the reference point. Suppose a body is located at some vertical distance above a fixed horizontal reference or datum. In that case, the weight of the body has positive gravitational potential...
993
Standard Electrode Potentials03:02

Standard Electrode Potentials

On comparing the reactivity of silver and lead, it is observed that the two ionic species, Ag+ (aq) and Pb2+ (aq), show a difference in their redox reactivity towards copper: the silver ion undergoes spontaneous reduction, while the lead ion does not. This relative redox activity can be easily quantified in electrochemical cells by a property called cell potential. This property is commonly known as cell voltage in electrochemistry, and it is a measure of the energy which accompanies the charge...
50.1K
Cell Potential and Free Energy02:58

Cell Potential and Free Energy

Thermodynamics of a Redox Reaction
Thermodynamics is the branch of physics dealing with the relationship between heat and other forms of energy. In an electrochemical cell, chemical energy is converted into electrical energy.
Thus, a link can be predicted between cell potential, free energy change, and the equilibrium constant for the reaction. Cell potential can also be measured as the oxidant or the reducing strength, and similar acid-base strength measures are reflected in equilibrium...
46.4K