First-order and continuous melting transitions in two-dimensional Lennard-Jones systems and repulsive disks

In two-dimensional Lennard-Jones (LJ) systems, a small interval of melting-mode switching occurs below which the melting occurs by first-order phase transitions in lieu of the melting scenario proposed by Kosterlitz, Thouless, Halperin, Nelson, and Young (KTHNY). The extrapolated upper bound for phase coexistence is at density ρ∼0.893 and temperature T∼1.1, both in reduced LJ units. The two-stage KTHNY scenario is restored at higher temperatures, and the isothermal melting scenario is universal. The solid-hexatic and hexatic-liquid transitions in KTHNY theory, even so continuous, are distinct from typical continuous phase transitions in that instead of scale-free fluctuations, they are characterized by unbinding of topological defects, resulting in a special form of divergence of the correlation length: ξ≈exp(b|T-T_{c}|^{-ν}). Here such a divergence is firmly established for a two-dimensional melting phenomenon, providing a conclusive proof of the KTHNY melting. We explicitly confirm that this high-temperature melting behavior of the LJ system is consistent with the melting behavior of the r^{-12} potential and that melting of the r^{-n} potential is KTHNY-like for n≤12 but melting of the r^{-64} potential is first order; similar to hard disks. Therefore we suggest that the melting scenario of these repulsive potentials becomes hard-disk-like for an exponent in the range 12