Varying Influence of Dairy Manure Injection on Phosphorus Loss in Runoff over Four Years

Surface application of manure on no-till farms can exacerbate P losses in runoff, contributing to the eutrophication of surface waters. We monitored 12 400-m field plots over 4 yr to compare P losses in surface runoff and lateral subsurface flow with shallow disk injection and broadcast application of dairy manure. Given the substantial variability in annual P losses, as well as a gradual, annual buildup of residual soil test P, significant differences in runoff P losses were detected in only 1 of 4 yr: in 2014, total P losses in runoff were 68% greater from broadcast manure plots than injected manure plots. Dissolved and particulate P were roughly even in their contribution to runoff. Even so, there were significant relationships between annual dissolved P losses and P in the soil surface, which pointed to soils as a regular source of P in runoff. Overall, results confirm the potential for injection to reduce P loss in runoff relative to broadcast application, but because in a few sampling dates injection resulted in greater losses, this study also highlights the importance of assessing mitigation benefits of manure application practices over longer timeframes.