Anticooperative Binding Governs the Mechanics of Ethidium-Complexed DNA

DNA intercalators bind nucleic acids by stacking between adjacent basepairs. This causes a considerable elongation of the DNA backbone as well as untwisting of the double helix. In the past few years, single-molecule mechanical experiments have become a common tool to characterize these deformations and to quantify important parameters of the intercalation process. Parameter extraction typically relies on the neighbor-exclusion model, in which a bound intercalator prevents intercalation into adjacent sites. Here, we challenge the neighbor-exclusion model by carefully quantifying and modeling the force-extension and twisting behavior of single ethidium-complexed DNA molecules. We show that only an anticooperative ethidium binding that allows for a disfavored but nonetheless possible intercalation into nearest-neighbor sites can consistently describe the mechanical behavior of intercalator-bound DNA. At high ethidium concentrations and elevated mechanical stress, this causes an almost complete occupation of nearest-neighbor sites and almost a doubling of the DNA contour length. We furthermore show that intercalation into nearest-neighbor sites needs to be considered when estimating intercalator parameters from zero-stress elongation and twisting data. We think that the proposed anticooperative binding mechanism may also be applicable to other intercalating molecules.