Are we getting any better? A study on repair integrity in 1600 consecutive arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs

Postoperative retear is the most common surgical complication after rotator cuff repair. This study aimed to determine whether there had been any improvements in rotator cuff repair integrity in our center and to identify any changes in the management of rotator cuff tears that may have impacted postoperative retear rate.

This retrospective observational single cohort study used running average analysis to examine 1600 consecutive patients over 8 years, who underwent primary arthroscopic rotator cuff repair by a single surgeon, and had cuff integrity assessed by ultrasound 6 months after operation.

Retear rates ranged from 3% to 34%, with a mean of 15%. Over our study retear rates decreased from 18% to 5%. Reductions in retear rates were associated with less aggressive rehabilitation, postoperative abduction sling use, and increased surgical experience. Increases in retear rates were associated with increased false positives with a more sensitive ultrasound machine and learning curves with new equipment for a surgeon and sonographer.

A decrease in retear rate after arthroscopic rotator cuff repair occurred during our study. Although the study design prevents us from directly attributing changes in retear rate to changes in management, our results suggest that rehabilitation optimization and increased surgeon experience decrease postoperative retear.