Living Donation by Individuals with Life-Limiting Conditions

Lainie Friedman Ross1, J Richard Thistlethwaite1

  • 1Lainie Friedman Ross, M.D., Ph.D., is the Carolyn and Matthew Bucksbaum Professor of Clinical Ethics, Professor, Departments of Pediatrics, Medicine and Surgery, Associate Director, MacLean Center for Clinical Medical Ethics, University of Chicago, Chicago IL. J. Richard Thistlethwaite, M.D., Ph.D., is Professor Emeritus, Department of Surgery and the MacLean Center for Clinical Medical Ethics, University of Chicago, Chicago IL.

Insights

Living organ donation is expanding to include less healthy individuals. This paper explores the ethical considerations of donation by those with life-limiting conditions, including severe debilitating diseases or imminent death.

Area of Science:

  • Transplantation ethics
  • Medical ethics
  • Organ donation policy

Background:

  • Traditional living organ donors were typically very healthy.
  • Increasing organ demand necessitates considering less healthy donors.
  • This paper examines the extreme of living donation by individuals with life-limiting conditions.

Observation:

  • Ethical dilemmas arise when considering donation from individuals with progressive, severe, debilitating diseases lacking curative treatments.
  • Further ethical questions emerge regarding donation from individuals who are imminently dying or would die as a direct result of the donation process.

Findings:

  • The paper identifies and discusses two primary ethical challenges in living organ donation.
  • These challenges involve individuals with severe, untreatable progressive illnesses and those at the end of life.

Implications:

  • This research informs ethical guidelines for organ transplantation programs.
  • It prompts critical discussion on expanding the donor pool while prioritizing donor safety and ethical integrity.
  • The findings contribute to policy development regarding organ donation from vulnerable populations.

Related Concept Videos

Classical Conditioning in Daily Life01:17

Classical Conditioning in Daily Life

Classical conditioning, a fundamental principle of associative learning, explains various phenomena observed in daily life, such as fear development, the placebo effect, taste aversion, and drug habituation. These applications demonstrate the profound impact of associative learning on human behavior and physiological responses.
John B. Watson and Rosalie Rayner famously demonstrated the development of fear through classical conditioning in their experiment with Little Albert. They paired the...
2.2K
Half-life of a Reaction02:42

Half-life of a Reaction

The half-life of a reaction (t1/2) is the time required for one-half of a given amount of reactant to be consumed. In each succeeding half-life, half of the remaining concentration of the reactant is consumed. For example, during the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide, during the first half-life (from 0.00 hours to 6.00 hours), the concentration of H2O2 decreases from 1.000 M to 0.500 M. During the second half-life (from 6.00 hours to 12.00 hours), the concentration decreases from 0.500 M to...
38.8K
Characteristics of Life01:23

Characteristics of Life

Biology is a natural science that studies life and living organisms, including their structure, function, development, interactions, evolution, distribution, and taxonomy. The field's scope is extensive and divided into several specialized disciplines, such as anatomy, physiology, ethology, genetics, and many more. All living things share a few key traits, including cellular organization, heritable genetic material and the ability to adapt/evolve, metabolism to regulate energy needs, the...
257.7K
Limiting Reactant02:27

Limiting Reactant

The relative amounts of reactants and products represented in a balanced chemical equation are often referred to as stoichiometric amounts. However, in reality, the reactants are not always present in the stoichiometric amounts indicated by the balanced equation.
69.6K
The Tree of Life - Bacteria, Archaea, Eukaryotes02:40

The Tree of Life - Bacteria, Archaea, Eukaryotes

The “tree of life” describes the evolution of life and the evolutionary relationships between organisms. The root of the tree is the common ancestor to all life on Earth. All other species radiate from this point, much like the branches of a tree. The numerous tips of these branches on the tree of life represent every living, or extant, species. Extinct species, which are species that no longer exist, can be found towards the center of the tree. Currently, these organisms, both...
38.1K
The Angiosperm Life Cycle02:39

The Angiosperm Life Cycle

Plants have a life cycle split between two multicellular stages: a haploid stage—with cells containing one set of chromosomes—and a diploid stage—with cells containing two sets of chromosomes. The haploid stage is the gamete-producing gametophyte, and the diploid stage is the spore-producing sporophyte.
72.2K