Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jan 24, 2026

A Molecular Readout of Long-term Olfactory Adaptation in C. elegans
Published on: December 22, 2012
Individual Physiological Adaptations Enable Selected Bacterial Taxa To Prevail during Long-Term Incubations
D P R Herlemann1,2, S Markert3,4, C Meeske5
1Leibniz Institute for Baltic Sea Research Warnemünde, Rostock, Germany Daniel.Herlemann@emu.ee.
Incubation experiments can alter bacterial communities, independent of manipulation. Internal carbon storage strategies, not just external factors, influence species success in long-term studies. This highlights the "bottle effect" in microbial ecology.
Area of Science:
- Microbial Ecology
- Environmental Microbiology
- Marine Biology
Background:
- Enclosure experiments are vital for studying environmental impacts on microbial communities.
- The
- bottle effect,
- or unintended incubation impacts, on complex bacterial communities remains poorly understood.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate how long-term batch incubations affect bacterial communities from different salinities.
- To differentiate between manipulation-induced changes and inherent community shifts due to incubation.
Main Methods:
- Combined metaproteomic profiling, 16S rRNA gene analysis, and cell counts.
- Analyzed bacterial communities from marine, mesohaline, and oligohaline conditions.
- Compared early-phase and late-phase (55 days) incubation samples.
Main Results:
- Early in incubation, communities differed significantly, with notable responses to dissolved organic carbon manipulation.
- After 55 days, marine and mesohaline communities were dominated by *Spongiibacter*, suggesting internal carbon storage and grazing resistance as key survival traits.
- Oligohaline communities showed sustained abundance of actinobacterial cluster I (hgc-I), indicating reliance on external recalcitrant carbon.
Conclusions:
- Species-specific traits, like carbon storage strategies, can drive community shifts independently of experimental manipulations in enclosure studies.
- While enclosure experiments are valuable, the "bottle effect" necessitates critical evaluation of microbial community composition changes.
- Understanding these inherent shifts enhances the interpretation of environmental manipulation experiments.
Related Concept Videos
Natural Selection and Adaptation
Beyond physical adaptations,...
What is Natural Selection?
Antibiotic Selection
Impact of Individuals on Individuals
Long-term Depression
Bacterial Signaling

