Investigation of comet assays under conditions mimicking ocular instillation administration in a three-dimensional reconstructed human corneal epithelial model

Purpose: A comet assay is one of the genotoxicity methods for evaluating the potential of chemicals to induce DNA strand breaks. To investigate the usefulness of comet assays for evaluating the genotoxic potential of ophthalmic solutions, a three-dimensional (3D) reconstructed human corneal epithelial model (3D corneal model) was exposed to conditions mimicking topical ocular instillation administration. Methods: The 3D corneal model was exposed to acridine orange, ethidium bromide, hydrogen peroxide, 1,1'-dimethyl-4,4'-bipyridinium dichloride (paraquat), 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide (4-NQO), acrylamide and methyl methanesulfonate (MMS). To mimic the ocular surface condition to which ophthalmic solutions are administered, the exposure time was set to 1 minute. Likewise, human corneal epithelial (HCE-T) cells, as monolayer cultured cells, were exposed to the same chemicals, for comparison. Results: In the 3D corneal model, the amount of DNA fragments was statistically significantly increased in cells treated with each of the test chemicals except acrylamide. In HCE-T cells, the amount of DNA fragments was statistically significantly increased in acridine orange-, ethidium bromide-, hydrogen peroxide-, 4-NQO- and MMS-treated cells but not in paraquat- or acrylamide-treated cells. In the 3D corneal model, the lowest concentrations at which we observed DNA damage were about 100 times higher than the concentrations in HCE-T cells. Since the 3D corneal model is morphologically similar to human corneal tissue, form a multilayer and having tight junctions, it may be that the test chemicals only permeated about 1% into the 3D corneal model. Conclusion: These results suggest that the comet assay using 3D cell culture models may reflect in vivo conditions better than do monolayer cultured cells, and that the comet assay may be useful for the evaluation of genotoxic potential of topical ophthalmic solution.