Cytoreductive surgery in advanced stage malignant ovarian germ cell tumors

To evaluate the survival effect of cytoreductive surgery in advanced stage malignant ovarian germ cell tumors (MOGCT).

Clinicopathological data of patients with MOGCT that were treated between 1991 and 2014. Maximal debulking was defined as no gross residual tumor after primary or recurrence surgery; optimal and suboptimal debulking were used for patients with residual tumors of ≤1cm and >1cm, respectively.

In total, 31 patients with advanced stage MOGCT were analyzed. The median age at diagnosis was 21 (14-57) years. The median follow-up duration was 64.1 months. Of these 31 patients; 7 patients underwent sub-optimal debulking, 5 patients had optimal surgery and 18 had maximal debulking. Five-year DFS according to surgical resection rates were 29% in suboptimal debulking group, 75% in optimal debulking group and 93% in maximal cytoreduction group (p<0.001). Three of seven patients who underwent sub-optimal debulking were died of disease, however no deaths were seen in patients with optimal and maximal debulking. Five-year OS was 32% in suboptimal debulking group, and 100% in optimal and maximal debulking groups (p=0.001).

The benefit of cytoreductive surgery is less well-established in MOGCT of ovary compared to ovarian tumors of epithelial origin due to rareness of this histological subtype. Patients with MOGCT are usually younger and preservation of fertility is an important issue which may lead to suboptimal procedures, sometimes in exchange for diminished survival. Our data demonstrated that maximal cytoreduction should be aimed in patients with advanced stage MOGCT, as it is significantly associated with improved overall survival.