Recurrence rate of odontogenic myxoma after different treatments: a systematic review

Our aim was to establish the recurrence rate of odontogenic myxoma after different treatments. Our search covered papers from 1972-2017 from different sources. The papers were evaluated and critically appraised by two independent investigators. The recurrence rate and 95% CI were calculated in relation to each specific treatment, and the chi squared test was calculated to find out if there was any significant difference in the recurrence rate between conservative treatment and resection. The overall recurrence rate was 5 of 39 patients (13%) during a mean follow up period of 10 years. With conservative treatment the recurrence rate was 4/22 (19%) (mean follow up 11 years) and after resection it was 1/17 (6%) (mean follow up nine years). Maxillary lesions were more likely to recur than mandibular ones. Quality of life variables such as disfigurement and neural deficit were more common after resection than with conservative treatment. The frequency of recurrence was relatively low over 10 years' follow up, irrespective of whether resection or a more conservative approach was used, despite being slightly lower (as might be expected) after resection. Conservative treatment should be considered first to avoid resection-associated morbidity and the effect on the quality of life. Maxillary lesions have more room to spread before they are clinically evident, making them difficult to treat optimally and contributing to the recurrence rate.