A high-volume, low-cost approach to participant screening and enrolment: Experiences from the T4DM diabetes

Karen Bracken1, Anthony Keech1, Wendy Hague1

  • 1NHMRC Clinical Trials Centre, The University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.

Abstract

Insights

Recruiting for diabetes prevention trials is hard. A semi-automated, multi-step screening process, including web-based pre-screening, successfully enrolled participants in a testosterone trial at low cost.

Area of Science:

  • Clinical Trials
  • Endocrinology
  • Public Health

Background:

  • Participant recruitment for diabetes prevention randomized controlled trials (RCTs) presents significant challenges in terms of cost and logistics.
  • The Testosterone for Diabetes Management (T4DM) study, a Phase IIIb RCT, aimed to prevent Type 2 diabetes in men aged 50-74 years, facing high screening volume demands with limited resources.
  • This study evaluates an innovative, cost-effective, semi-automated screening strategy designed for high-volume participant enrollment.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To assess the efficacy of a semi-automated, multi-step screening process for participant recruitment in a large, multicenter diabetes prevention RCT.
  • To determine the cost-effectiveness and efficiency of a centralized, web-based screening approach compared to traditional methods.
  • To provide a scalable model for participant screening in similar clinical trial settings.

Main Methods:

  • A sequential, multi-step screening protocol was implemented, starting with web-based pre-screening, followed by laboratory screening at third-party centers, and concluding with on-site screening.
  • Online data collection, automated eligibility checks, and email-based communication were utilized, with phone and mail options available upon request.
  • The entire screening process was managed centrally by the coordinating center through a unified data management system.

Main Results:

  • The screening process required approximately 1.6 full-time equivalents over 4 years, screening 19,022 participants.
  • Out of 19,022 pre-screened individuals, 1007 were ultimately randomized into the trial.
  • The total cost for screening was AUD 1,420,909, equating to AUD 75 per subject screened and AUD 1411 per randomized participant, with 95% opting for online pre-screening.

Conclusions:

  • A multi-step, semi-automated screening approach, particularly with web-based pre-screening, effectively facilitated low-cost, high-volume participant enrollment for a large, multicenter RCT.
  • Centralization and automation of screening procedures led to significant cost savings compared to previous studies.
  • The developed screening methodology is adaptable to other RCT settings, offering a viable strategy to minimize participant screening costs.