Not the comfy chair! Cancer drugs that act against multiple active sites
Laurence Booth1, Andrew Poklepovic2, Paul Dent1
1Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA, USA.
Abstract:
Introduction: Discoveries of novel signal transduction pathways in the 1990s stimulated drug companies to develop small molecule tyrosine kinase and serine / threonine kinase inhibitors which were based on catalytic site inhibition. All kinases bind ATP and catalyze phosphate transfer and, therefore, inhibitors that block ATP binding and its metabolism would be predicted to have a known on-target specificity but were also likely to have many unknown or unrecognized targets due to similarities in all ATP binding pockets. This on-target off-target biology of kinase inhibitors, which exhibit a "signal" in the clinic, means that therapeutically valuable agents are acting through unknown biological processes to mediate their anti-tumor effects.Areas covered: This perspective discusses drug therapies whose actions cannot be explained by their actions on the original targeted kinase; it concludes with a methodology to screen for changes in cell signaling via in-cell western immunoblotting.Expert opinion: Most malignancies do not depend on survival signaling from one specific mutated proto-oncogene, especially for previously treated malignancies where multiple clonal variants of the primary tumor have evolved. Hence, the concept of a highly "personalized medicine" approach fails because it is unlikely that a specific therapy will kill all clonal variants of the tumor.
Insights
Small molecule kinase inhibitors, targeting ATP binding sites, often hit unintended targets. This leads to anti-tumor effects through unknown biological pathways, challenging personalized medicine approaches for diverse cancers.
Area of Science:
- Oncology
- Pharmacology
- Molecular Biology
Background:
- Small molecule kinase inhibitors were developed based on catalytic site inhibition.
- Kinase inhibitors targeting ATP binding sites have predicted on-target specificity but also unknown off-targets due to conserved ATP pockets.
- The "on-target off-target biology" of kinase inhibitors means their therapeutic effects can stem from unknown biological processes.
Purpose of the Study:
- To discuss drug therapies whose actions are not explained by their primary kinase target.
- To propose a methodology for screening cell signaling changes.
- To address the limitations of personalized medicine in treating heterogeneous malignancies.
Main Methods:
- Review of drug therapies and their mechanisms of action.
- Discussion of in-cell western immunoblotting for screening cell signaling.
- Analysis of tumor heterogeneity and clonal evolution.
Main Results:
- Kinase inhibitors can exert anti-tumor effects through mechanisms beyond their initially targeted kinase.
- In-cell western immunoblotting offers a method to investigate these signaling alterations.
- Tumor clonal evolution in treated patients leads to heterogeneity, complicating single-target therapies.
Conclusions:
- Therapeutic benefits of kinase inhibitors may arise from inhibiting unintended targets.
- A shift in therapeutic strategy is needed beyond targeting single mutated oncogenes.
- The complexity of cancer necessitates approaches that account for tumor heterogeneity and off-target effects.
More Related Videos
Related Concept Videos
Targeted Cancer Therapies
There are several types of targeted therapies against...
Treatment Resistant Cancers
Combination Therapies and Personalized Medicine
The combination of the drug acetazolamide and sulforaphane is a good example of combination therapy to treat cancer. The cells in the interior of a large tumor often die due to the hypoxic and...
Targets for Drug Action: Overview
Receptors are either membrane-spanning or intracellular proteins, which upon binding a ligand, get activated and transmit the signal downstream to elicit a response. Drugs bind receptors, either mimicking the action of endogenous ligands or blocking the receptor activity to bring about a modified response. Nearly 35% of approved drugs target the G...
Drugs that Destabilize Microtubules
Drugs that Stabilize Microtubules


