Future Balloon-Expandable Stents: High or Low-Strength Materials?

Recent progress in material science allows researchers to use novel materials with enhanced capabilities like optimum biodegradability, higher strength, and flexibility in the design of coronary stents. Considering the wide range of mechanical properties of existing and newfangled materials, finding the influence of variations in mechanical properties of stent materials is critical for developing a practical design.

The sensitivity of stent functional characteristics to variations in its material plastic properties is obtained through FEM modeling. Balloon-expandable coronary stent designs: Absorb BVS, and Xience are examined for artificial and commercial polymeric, and metallic materials, respectively. Standard tests including (1) the crimping process followed by stent implantation in an atherosclerotic artery and (2) the three-point bending test, have been simulated according to ASTM standards.

In Absorb BVS, materials with higher yield stress than PLLA have similar residual deflection and maximum bending force to PLLA, which is not the case for Xience stent and Co-Cr. Moreover, elevated yield stress significantly reduces stent flexibility only in Xience stent. For both stents, with different degree of influence, an increase in yield or ultimate stress improves stent radial strength and stiffness and reduces arterial stress and plastic strain of stent, which consequently enhances the stent mechanical performance. Contrarily, yield or ultimate stress elevation increases stent recoil which adversely affects stent performance.

Using high-strength materials has a double-edged sword effect on the stent performance and existing uncertainty in the precise estimate of stent mechanical properties adversely affects the reliability of numerical models' predictions.