Integrating stereopsis with monocular interpretations of planar surfaces

Experiments are reported that involved spatial judgments of planar surfaces that had contradictory stereo and monocular information. Tasks included comparing the relative depths of two points on the depicted surface and judging the surface's apparent spatial orientation. It was found that for planar surfaces the 3D perception was dominated by the monocular interpretation, despite the strongly contradictory stereo information. We propose that stereo information is effectively integrated only where the surface exhibits curvature features or edge discontinuities, i.e. where the second spatial derivatives of disparity are nonzero. Planar surfaces induce constant gradients of disparity and are thus effectively featureless to stereopsis. Further observations are reported regarding nonplanar surfaces, where contradictory monocular information can still be effectively rivalrous with that suggested stereoscopically.