Related Experiment Video
Updated: Dec 31, 2025
Standardized Histomorphometric Evaluation of Osteoarthritis in a Surgical Mouse Model
Published on: May 6, 2020
Developing a Novel Scoring System to Objectively Track Orthopaedic Resident Educational Performance and Progression
Chad A Krueger1, Jessica C Rivera1, Preetinder S Bhullar1
1San Antonio Uniformed Services Healthcare Education Consortium, Fort Sam Houston, Texas.
Objective:
Objectively determining orthopedic resident competence remains difficult and lacks standardization across residency programs. We sought to develop a scoring system to measure resident educational activity to stratify participation and performance in particular aspects of training and the effect of these measures on board certification.
Design:
A weighted scoring system (Average Resident Score, ARS) was developed using the number of logged cases, clinic notes dictated, OITE PGY percentile, case minimums met, and scholarly activity completed each academic year (AY), with clinical activity being more heavily weighted. The Resident Effectiveness Score (RES), a z-score showing the number of standard deviations from the mean, was determined using the ARS. The RES effect on the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) Milestones and American Board of Orthopedic Surgery (ABOS) Part 1 percentile score was determined using a Spearman correlation.
Setting:
Large academic orthopedic residency.
Participants:
Thirty one orthopedic residents graduating between 2011 and 2016 were included.
Results:
The RES did not differ between classes in the same AY, nor change significantly for individual residents during their training. Milestone z-scores increased as residents progressed in their education. The RES correlated with each Milestone competency subscore. The PGY5 OITE score and achieving ACGME minimums correlated with passing ABOS Part 1 (28/31 1st time pass), but the RES did not predict passing the board examination.
Conclusions:
This study demonstrates a scoring system encompassing multiple facets of resident education to track resident activity and progress. The RES can be tailored to an individual program's goals and aims and help program directors identify residents not maximizing educational opportunities compared to their peers. Monitoring this score may allow tailoring of educational efforts to individual resident needs. This RES may also allow residents to measure their performance and educational accomplishments and adjust their focus to obtain competence and board certification.
