Activation by substoichiometric inhibition

Startling reports described the paradoxical triggering of the human mitogen-activated protein kinase pathway when a small-molecule inhibitor specifically inactivates the BRAF V600E protein kinase but not wt-BRAF. We performed a conceptual analysis of the general phenomenon "activation by inhibition" using bacterial and human HtrA proteases as models. Our data suggest a clear explanation that is based on the classic biochemical principles of allostery and cooperativity. Although substoichiometric occupancy of inhibitor binding sites results in partial inhibition, this effect is overrun by a concomitant activation of unliganded binding sites. Therefore, when an inhibitor of a cooperative enzyme does not reach saturating levels, a common scenario during drug administration, it may cause the contrary of the desired effect. The implications for drug development are discussed.