Comparing Different Methods of Hand-crafted HRV, EDR and CPC Features for Sleep Apnoea Detection

In this paper, we extracted hand crafted features from the ECG signals and evaluated the performance of different combination of features for sleep apnoea detection. We calculated the ECG derived respiratory (EDR) signal using three methods (QRS area, amplitude demodulation and fast PCA methods) and then calculated the cardiopulmonary coupling (CPC) spectrum using each EDR method. We then extracted features from the CPC spectrums and the time and frequency representations of the heart rate variability (HRV) and EDR signals Then, we compared the performance results of different combinations of the features used for automated sleep apnoea detection. We also applied a temporal optimisation method by averaging the features of every three adjacent epochs. Two classifiers were used to detect sleep apnoea: the extreme learning machine (ELM), and linear discriminant analysis. The features were evaluated on the MIT PhysioNet Apnea-ECG database. Apnoea detection was evaluated with leave-one-record-out cross-validation. The PCA CPC features obtained the highest accuracy of 86.5% and AUC of 0.94 using LDA classifier. The performance results of the combined features (of PCA method) obtained the same results. We conclude that for this study, the CPC features using fast PCA method are our best feature set for sleep apnoea detection.