An evaluation of competitive and second generation ELISA screening tests for antibody to HIV

Two competitive anti-HIV ELISA screening assays (Behring and Wellcozyme) and two second generation assays using antigens generated by recombinant DNA technology (Abbott) and synthetic peptides (Biochrom) were evaluated against common panels of anti-HIV positive sera and sera known or thought likely to give false positive reactions. The assays were also tested on fresh sequential blood donations. Conventional estimates of sensitivity and specificity did not reveal a significant difference between the assays. Statistical analyses using log10 transformed data to determine delta values (the distance of the mean optical density (OD) ratio from the cut-off measured in standard deviation units) showed the Abbott assays to have the highest probability (greater than 99.99%) of detecting anti-HIV positive samples and the Behring assay as having the highest probability (greater than 99.99%) of correctly identifying anti-HIV negative specimens. The combined data from conventional estimates of sensitivity and specificity and delta values suggests that the Abbott assay is the test of choice for screening purposes.