A computational analysis of retinal image quality in eyes with keratoconus

Higher-order aberrations (HOA's) are exaggerated in eyes with keratoconus but little is known about their impact on the retinal image quality (IQ) of these eyes. This computational study determined changes in IQ [peak IQ, best focus and depth of focus (DOF)] of 12 subjects with manifest keratoconus in both eyes (KCE cohort), 9 subjects with very asymmetric ectasia (VAE cohort) with and without their Rigid Gas Permeable contact lenses (RGP CL's) and 20 age-matched controls, using a HOA-based through-focus analysis performed on the logNS IQ metric over 5 mm pupil diameter following cycloplegia. All IQ parameters were significantly worse in the KCE cohort with their native HOA's, relative to controls and in the ectatic eye of the VAE cohort, relative to the fellow non-ectatic eye (p ≤ 0.008 for all). Reduction in HOA's of these eyes with RGP CL's resulted in a significant improvement in all IQ parameters but they all remained significantly poorer than controls (p ≤ 0.02 for all). The inter-subject variability of best focus and the DOF range were inversely related to peak IQ in these eyes (r = 0.85; p < 0.001). These results provide the optical basis for two clinical observations on keratoconus: (1) optical performance of keratoconic eyes are significantly better with RGP CL's than with spectacles or unaided conditions and (2) the endpoint of subjective refraction is elusive in keratoconic eyes, relative to healthy controls or to the non-ectatic eye in bilaterally asymmetric ectasia.