Related Experiment Video
Updated: Dec 29, 2025
Learning Modern Laryngeal Surgery in a Dissection Laboratory
Published on: March 18, 2020
Mapping the centers performing endocrine neck surgery in Italy
Background:
Quality of care and provider's experience seem to be strictly connected in any field of surgery. Aim of this study is to identify a method to classify the centers on the basis of the number of thyroidectomies and parathyroidectomies performed.
Methods:
We listed 666 centers performing endocrine neck surgery in 2015, from the database of the Italian Health Ministry. We performed a descriptive statistic analysis with a dedicated software. We identified the outliers, according to a previous literature review, in those centers performing >1000 and < 10 thyroidectomies, >100 and < 3 parathyroidectomies and we excluded them to our analysis. The remaining centers were grouped in a box-plot. Third quartile, median, procedures performed/3rd quartile value ratio (Standardized Hospitalization Ratio, SHR, superior cut-off), Romamedian/3rd quartile values ratio (inferior cut-off) were calculated. These centers were charted in a bar graph and three zones were identified: "excellence" (SHR>1.1), "SHR", "alert" (between the two cut-offs) and "risk" (under the lower cut-off).
Results:
35743 thyroidectomies and 2306 parathyroidectomies were performed in Italy in 2015. After the outliers' exclusion, 407 and 157 centers performing respectively thyroidectomies and parathyroidectomies were analysed. A median value of respectively 37 thyroidectomies and 6 parathyroidectomies, and a 3rd quartile cut-off of respectively 85 and 12 were calculated. Concerning all the 666 centers, we found: 95 excellence centers for thyroidectomy and 33 for parathyroidectomy, respectively 18 and 17 falling into superior cut-off line, 100 and 29 in the alert zone, 453 and 587 in the risk zone.
Conclusions:
Our method, according to the literature data, highlighted a number of thyroidectomies and parathyroidectomies performed in low volume centers. Looking for an optimization in health organization, we can consider some measures such as a net of tutorship of the "alert" hospitals by the excellence ones and a discouragement of the "risk" hospitals in performing endocrine neck surgery.
